4 May 2019

Calling God: A Thee/You Discussion


            A few weeks ago, my friend and I were having a delightful conversation at the pub. We were chatting about addressing God. (Oh yes, friends, I'm super fun to chat theology with on a Friday night!)
            At any rate - my friend (and colleague) indicated a hesitancy to maintaining some of the previously used language when we are educating and pastoring a younger congregation. Specifically, we were debating the "Thee" and "Thou" and "Thy" formalities of a bygone era, within the context of the Lord's Prayer.
            My friend makes a good point: in no other place do we use such language; even to address royalty one uses "Your" majesty/highness/excellency. The world has changed; the language has changed. Trying to teach a younger generation (including baby boomers, by the way) to use the highest formalities necessitates an awareness of archaic linguistics. (It was written before Shakespeare, and we all know how delightfully clear that language is to understand!)
            And yet, for so many in our midst, the Lord's Prayer just isn't the Lord's Prayer unless it does use those words.
            Our pub decision was that this was a conundrum that would not be easily solved; yet we acknowledged two truths... first, as polyglots (having at least rudimentary knowledge of more than one language), we identify that English provides linguistic limitation in it's absence of formal address provision (which other languages automatically include: for example, Vous vs Tu in French).
            Secondly, we agreed that come judgment, when we stand before the Throne of Grace, we hope that we will be wise enough to bow before God's majesty and acknowledge the source of love and life with the utmost respect and authority. If God wants to hear a "Thee" from me, I will not refuse!
            Fast forward to this week, when we briefly revisited the topic, this time within the context of Imago Dei, a theology based on every human bearing the image and likeness of God. The conundrum deepens... if we, looking at the presence of Christ in one another, are comfortable using the informal "you", then to differentiate with God in heaven as "Thou" seems to deny that Imago Dei in language, and possibly beyond.
            A very valid concern with broad-reaching implications!
            Yet I countered with my friend by turning the question: However we address God, have we ever considered how God addresses us? Does God use the language of the King James Bible with us? Or one of the ancient Biblical languages? Or modern English to prevent confusion? Does it matter, so long as we are continuing conversations with our Creator?
            It is my belief that God's language speaks into our hearts in such an intimate and loving way that it celebrates the Imago within, delights in the whispers of our hearts, and communicates perfect grace to every aspect of our soul. And when that happens, it transcends all human language - in all its versions.

No comments:

Post a Comment